For John, BLUF: Maybe it isn't good for everyone to be all excited about politics. Nothing to see here; just move along.
Fiction writer Sarah Hoyt is cranky and lets us know it. Her blog post is "A State of Ignorance and An Ignorance of State".
She is in a lather over people who are in a lather over the fact that most Americans don't really have a handle on either government or politics. By government, I mean the Constitution and how things work, or don't, from Capitol Hill, in DC, to their local town or city. As a point of reference, when, in the Blog Post, she says "partly because I lived in times when not knowing who was likely to gain power the next turn could cost you your life (a lot of people become engaged in those circumstances)" she is talking growing up in Portugal under Salazar up through the Carnation Revolution.
Somewhere in the Blog Post she says:
The problem we have right now is the confusing of politics with social clubs. A lot of this has always happened. Hereditary democrats who don’t believe anything the democrats are promising vote democrat because their local Ward people met their immigrant grandfather coming off the boat and helped. So, in gratitude, they keep voting democrat.She wraps up the blog post thusly:But it is worse now, because there are a lot fewer other (local) clubs and sports are less … uh… fewer people care about sports. So people identify with a party in the same way that people would identify with a sports fandom. They vote democrat because their neighbors do. Other people do it was a status thing “All of my industry votes democrat. It’s what smart people do.”
As I said, this has always happened, but it’s become more so as the mass media – note I used all democrat above. There’s a reason – has worked very hard to foster this kind of clubbish partisanship. (Including reporting everything stupid a republican says and keeping mum about things like Guam tipping over and/or having to pass the law to find what’s in it.)
Pray. Pray very constantly that the crash isn’t bad enough to wake the rest of the people. PRAY that there is never a state of affairs where your survival depends on almost everyone knowing the constitution and being able to tell you if they’re for or against each amendment.Hat tip to the Instapundit.Because that will mean a state of unimaginable chaos and fear and possibly a tri-or-four part civil war.
Let’s hope it doesn’t come to that. Let’s hope it’s never required that the majority of the people be THAT well informed.
Regards — Cliff
GOOD FOR SARAH!!!!! She is absolutely 100% on the mark. I have often thought that in order to vote in an election, one must take and pass a written test about the level of government and issues being voted on. It would certainly speed up and simplify vote counting...that much is for certain.
ReplyDeleteI am convinced that people vote today because of intellectual laziness. We are a instant gratification nation. We love our food fast and not complex. We love our information fast and not complex....a perfect market for predigested pablum for the masses. Everything we know today we learned each day between 6:30 and 7:00 PM on one of three channels, ABC, CBS, or NBC depending on what talking head one prefers. Then it's time for Chronicle or Extra with more predigested feel good information and then right into Prime Time and "REALITY" TV...except that it isn't much. I would venture that in the hours of Prime Time (a cousin of EDT, CDT, MDT, and PDT (except for AZ and IN...and NOBODY can figure out IN), 75% of the brain cells in the US population are on low power, pre-sleep mode.
Why did you vote Democrat/Republican (you pick)? I dunno, I like what I heard. There you have it. Say the right words, and folks fall at your feet in rapt adoration. And we call humans "higher intelligence." My dog does the same thing.