Follow the Science

For John, BLUF:  Teachers, and students, should be returning to the classrooms, in person.  Nothing to see here; just move along.

---

When the White House can't handle the truth

From The Washington Examiner, by Chief Political Correspondent Byron York, 5 February 2021, 08:39 AM.

Here is the lede plus six:

On January 21, President Biden’s first full day in office, White House press secretary Jen Psaki began her briefing with this:  “When the president asked me to serve in this role, we talked about the importance of bringing truth and transparency back to the briefing room.”  Now, the administration’s position on opening schools shut by COVID lockdowns is testing that pledge.

Psaki’s problem started on Wednesday, when the White House COVID Response Team held a teleconference for the press.  Among the group was Dr. Rochelle Walensky, the president’s new choice to head the Centers for Disease Control.  A reporter asked Walensky about the CDC’s priorities for vaccination, and in particular whether “the federal government would be working more closely with states to kind of get more vaccinations to teachers in particular so that schools can reopen in the fall.”

Walensky said that a group inside the CDC, the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, or ACIP, had created a priority list for those receiving vaccinations.  In December, the committee included teachers in what was called the 1b category, meaning they would be among those who should be next in line.  But that wasn’t law — it was the CDC’s guidance for states to follow, or not to follow.

“We’ve left that to the states to manage,” Walensky explained, “in terms of recognizing the prioritization of ACIP, but also manage at their own local level.”

And then: “That said, I want to be very clear about schools, which is:  Yes, ACIP has put teachers in the 1b category, the category of essential workers.  But I also want to be clear that there is increasing data to suggest that schools can safely reopen and that that safe reopening does not suggest that teachers need to be vaccinated in order to reopen safely.  So while we are implementing the criteria of the Advisory Committee and of the state and local guidances to get vaccination across these eligible communities, I would also say that safe reopening of schools is not — that vaccination of teachers is not a prerequisite for safe reopening of schools.”

There it was: The head of the CDC frankly stating that the science shows schools can safely reopen, and that the reopening of the schools does not depend on vaccinating teachers.  Given the current debate, in which teachers unions, the longtime allies and benefactors of Democratic politicians from Joe Biden on down, are demanding that schools remain closed and that teachers be vaccinated before any reopening can occur, Walensky’s statement was big news.  Would Democratic officeholders listen to the science and break with the unions?

It was such big news that the White House immediately ran away from it.

There are two issues here.  The first is that this White House, notwithstanding the promises to be different from the Trump Administration, is trying to curate the news to meet the interests of various constituencies.  Business as usual.

The second issue is getting our students back to school.  The science seems to say that we can reopen schools, but the Teachers Unions are saying no.  I can see their concern that if the CDC (Centers For Disease Control and Prevention) is wrong, it could be a serious problem for teachers.  However, it is the science.  I thought we are about following the science.  Are we?

Then there is the cui bono question.  If, as COVID-19 goes on, Student performance declines, if teachers are not in the classroom they can distance themselves from said decline.  And, they are still getting paid.

For sure, the White House hung CDC Director Dr. Rochelle Walensky out to dry on this one.  Not a good look.

Hat tip to the InstaPundit.

Regards  —  Cliff