Dystopian View

For John, BLUF:  People like Antonio Gramsci have been providing intellectual cover for American Marxists for decades.  Nothing to see here; just move along.

---

Gramscian damage

From the Blog Armed and Dangerous, by "esr", 11 February 2006.

Here is the lede plus six:

Americans have never really understood ideological warfare.  Our gut-level assumption is that everybody in the world really wants the same comfortable material success we have.  We use “extremist” as a negative epithet.  Even the few fanatics and revolutionary idealists we have, whatever their political flavor, expect everybody else to behave like a bourgeois.

We don’t expect ideas to matter — or, when they do, we expect them to matter only because people have been flipped into a vulnerable mode by repression or poverty.  Thus all our divagation about the “root causes” of Islamic terrorism, as if the terrorists’ very clear and very ideological account of their own theory and motivations is somehow not to be believed.

By contrast, ideological and memetic warfare has been a favored tactic for all of America’s three great adversaries of the last hundred years — Nazis, Communists, and Islamists. All three put substantial effort into cultivating American proxies to influence U.S. domestic policy and foreign policy in favorable directions.  Yes, the Nazis did this, through organizations like the “German-American Bund” that was outlawed when World War II went hot.  Today, the Islamists are having some success at manipulating our politics through fairly transparent front organizations like the Council on American-Islamic Relations.

But it was the Soviet Union, in its day, that was the master of this game.  They made dezinformatsiya (disinformation) a central weapon of their war against “the main adversary”, the U.S.  They conducted memetic subversion against the U.S. on many levels at a scale that is only now becoming clear as historians burrow through their archives and ex-KGB officers sell their memoirs.

The Soviets had an entire “active measures” department devoted to churning out anti-American dezinformatsiya.  A classic example is the rumor that AIDS was the result of research aimed at building a ‘race bomb’ that would selectively kill black people.

On a different level, in the 1930s members of CPUSA (the Communist Party of the USA) got instructions from Moscow to promote non-representational art so that the US’s public spaces would become arid and ugly.

Americans hearing that last one tend to laugh.  But the Soviets, following the lead of Marxist theoreticians like Antonio Gramsci, took very seriously the idea that by blighting the U.S.’s intellectual and esthetic life, they could sap Americans’ will to resist Communist ideology and an eventual Communist takeover.  The explicit goal was to erode the confidence of America’s ruling class and create an ideological vacuum to be filled by Marxism-Leninism.

This erosion of confidence in American culture is a serious and ongoing problem.

Hat tip to the InstaPundit.

Regards  —  Cliff